| NFC |
| Pos. | Starter(s) | Reserves |
| Quarterback | Kurt Warner, Arizona | Drew Brees, New Orleans Eli Manning, New York Giants |
| Running back | Adrian Peterson, Minnesota | Michael Turner, Atlanta Clinton Portis, Washington |
| Fullback | Mike Sellers, Washington | |
| Wide receiver | Larry Fitzgerald, Arizona Anquan Boldin, Arizona | Steve Smith, Carolina Roddy White, Atlanta |
| Tight end | Jason Witten, Dallas | Chris Cooley, Washington |
| Tackle | Jordan Gross, Carolina Walter Jones, Seattle* | Chris Samuels, Washington* Flozell Adams, Cowboys** Jammal Brown, Saints** |
| Guard | Steve Hutchinson, Minnesota Chris Snee, New York Giants | Leonard Davis, Dallas* Davin Joseph, Tampa Bay** |
| Center | Andre Gurode, Dallas | Shaun O'Hara, New York Giants |
| Pos. | Starter(s) | Reserves |
| Defensive end | Julius Peppers, Carolina Justin Tuck, New York Giants | Jared Allen, Minnesota |
| Defensive tackle | Kevin Williams, Minnesota Jay Ratliff, Dallas | Pat Williams, Minnesota |
| Outside linebacker | DeMarcus Ware, Dallas Lance Briggs, Chicago | Derrick Brooks, Tampa Bay* Julian Peterson, Seahawks** |
| Inside linebacker | Patrick Willis, San Francisco | Jon Beason, Carolina |
| Cornerback | Charles Woodson, Green Bay* Antoine Winfield, Minnesota | Asante Samuel, Philadelphia* Ronde Barber, Tampa Bay** Al Harris, Green Bay** |
| Free safety | Nick Collins, Green Bay | Brian Dawkins, Philadelphia |
| Strong safety | Adrian Wilson, Arizona | |
| Pos. | Starter(s) | Reserves |
| Punter | Jeff Feagles, New York Giants | |
| Placekicker | John Carney, New York Giants | |
| Kick returner | Clifton Smith, Tampa Bay | |
| Special teamer | Sean Morey, Arizona | Zak DeOssie, New York Giants*** |
| AFC |
| Pos. | Starter(s) | Reserves |
| Quarterback | Peyton Manning, Indianapolis | Brett Favre, New York Jets* Jay Cutler, Denver Kerry Collins, Tennessee** |
| Running back | Thomas Jones, New York Jets | Chris Johnson, Tennessee* Ronnie Brown, Miami Marshawn Lynch, Buffalo** |
| Fullback | Le'Ron McClain, Baltimore | |
| Wide receiver | Andre Johnson, Houston Brandon Marshall, Denver | Reggie Wayne, Indianapolis Wes Welker, New England |
| Tight end | Tony Gonzalez, Kansas City | Owen Daniels, Houston** Antonio Gates, San Diego*
| |
| Tackle | Joe Thomas, Cleveland Jason Peters, Buffalo* | Michael Roos, Tennessee Jake Long, Miami** | |
| Guard | Alan Faneca, New York Jets Kris Dielman, San Diego | Brian Waters, Kansas City |
| Center | Kevin Mawae, Tennessee* | Nick Mangold, New York Jets Casey Wiegmann, Denver** |
| Pos. | Starter(s) | Reserves |
| Defensive end | Mario Williams, Houston Dwight Freeney, Indianapolis | Robert Mathis, Indianapolis |
| Defensive tackle | Albert Haynesworth, Tennessee Kris Jenkins, New York Jets | Shaun Rogers, Cleveland |
| Outside linebacker | James Harrison, Pittsburgh Joey Porter, Miami | Terrell Suggs, Baltimore |
| Inside linebacker | Ray Lewis, Baltimore | James Farrior, Pittsburgh |
| Cornerback | Nnamdi Asomugha, Oakland Cortland Finnegan, Tennessee | Darrelle Revis, New York Jets |
| Free safety | Ed Reed, Baltimore | |
| Strong safety | Troy Polamalu, Pittsburgh | Chris Hope, Tennessee |
| Pos. | Starter(s) | Reserves |
| Punter | Shane Lechler, Oakland | |
| Placekicker | Stephen Gostkowski, New England | |
| Kick returner | Leon Washington, New York Jets | |
| Special teamer | Brendon Ayanbadejo, Baltimore | Ryan Pontbriand, Cleveland Browns*** |